Research ArticleOriginal Article
Effectiveness of Interventions to Increase Papanicolaou Smear Use
K. Robin Yabroff, Patricia Mangan and Jeanne Mandelblatt
The Journal of the American Board of Family
Practice May 2003, 16 (3) 188-203; DOI: https://doi.org/10.3122/jabfm.16.3.188
K. Robin Yabroff
PhD, MBA
Patricia Mangan
Jeanne Mandelblatt
MD, MPH

References
- ↵Clarke EA, Anderson TW. Does screening by “Pap” smears help prevent cervical cancer? A case-control study. Lancet 1979; 2: 1–4.
- ↵
- ↵Blackman DK, Bennett EM, Miller DS. Trends in self-reported use of mammograms (1989–1997) and Papanicolaou tests (1991–1997)—Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System. Morbid Mortal Wkly Rep CDC Surveill Summ 1999; 48: 1–22.
- ↵Breen N, Wagener DK, Brown ML, Davis WW, Ballard-Barbash R. Progress in cancer screening over a decade: results of cancer screening from the 1987, 1992 and 1998 National Health Interview Surveys. J Natl Cancer Inst 2001; 93: 1704–13.
- ↵
- ↵Hayward RA, Shapiro MF, Freeman HE, Corey CR. Who gets screened for cervical and breast cancer? Results from a new national survey. Arch Intern Med 1988; 148: 1177–81.
- ↵
- ↵Calle EE, Flanders WD, Thun MJ, Martin LM. Demographic predictors of mammography and Pap smear screening in US women. Am J Public Health 1993; 83: 53–60.
- Celentano DD, Klassen AC, Weisman CS, Rosenshein NB. Cervical cancer screening practices among older women: results from the Maryland Cervical Cancer Case-Control Study. J Clin Epidemiol 1988; 41: 531–41.
- Anderson LM, May DS. Has the use of cervical, breast, and colorectal cancer screening increased in the United States? Am J Public Health 1995; 85: 840–2.
- ↵Elnicki DM, Morris DK, Shockcor WT. Patient-perceived barriers to preventive health care among indigent, rural Appalachian patients. Arch Intern Med 1995; 155: 421–4.
- ↵Mandelblatt J, Traxler M, Lakin P, Kanetsky P, Kao R. Mammography and Papanicolaou smear use by elderly poor black women. The Harlem Study Team. J Am Geriatr Soc 1992; 40: 1001–7.
- ↵Mamon JA, Shediac MC, Crosby CB, Sanders B, Matanoski GM, Celentano DD. Inner-city women at risk for cervical cancer: behavioral and utilization factors related to inadequate screening. Prev Med 1990; 19: 363–76.
- ↵Howe HL, Bzduch H. A survey of Pap smear screening in upstate New York. NY State J Med 1986; 86: 291–6.
- Wilcox LS, Mosher WD. Factors associated with obtaining health screening among women of reproductive age. Public Health Rep 1993; 108: 76–86.
- ↵Ramirez AG, Suarez L, Laufman L, Barroso C, Chalela P. Hispanic women’s breast and cervical cancer knowledge, attitudes, and screening behaviors. Am J Health Promot 2000; 14: 292–300.
- ↵
- ↵
- ↵Potosky AL, Breen N, Graubard BI, Parsons PE. The association between health care coverage and the use of cancer screening tests. Results from the 1992 National Health Interview Survey. Med Care 1998; 36: 257–70.
- Gilliland FD, Mahler R, Hunt WC, Davis SM. Preventive health care among rural American Indians in New Mexico. Prev Med 1999; 28: 194–202.
- ↵McPhee SJ, Bird JA, Davis T, Ha NT, Jenkins CN, Le B. Barriers to breast and cervical cancer screening among Vietnamese-American women. Am J Prev Med 1997; 13: 205–13.
- ↵Suarez L, Pulley L. Comparing acculturation scales and their relationship to cancer screening among older Mexican-American women. J Natl Cancer Inst Monogr 1995; 18: 41–7.
- ↵Norman SA, Talbott EO, Kuller LH, Krampe BR, Stolley PD. Demographic, psychosocial, and medical correlates of Pap testing: a literature review. Am J Prev Med 1991; 7: 219–26.
- ↵
- ↵Ayanian JZ, Kohler BA, Abe T, Epstein AM. The relation between health insurance coverage and clinical outcomes among women with breast cancer. N Engl J Med 1993; 329: 326–31.
- ↵Ries LAG, Eisner MP, Kosary CL, et al, editors. SEER cancer statistics review, 1973–1999. Bethesda, Md: National Cancer Institute, 2000. Available at http://seer.cancer.gov/csr/1973_1999/2002.
- Mitchell JB, McCormack LA. Time trends in late-stage diagnosis of cervical cancer. Differences by race/ethnicity and income. Med Care 1997; 35: 1220–4.
- Breen N, Figueroa JB. Stage of breast and cervical cancer diagnosis in disadvantaged neighborhoods: a prevention policy perspective. Am J Prev Med 1996; 12: 319–26.
- ↵Healthy people 2010: understanding and improving health. 2nd ed. Washington, DC: US Department of Health and Human Services, 2000.
- ↵
- ↵Grady KE, Lemkau JP, McVay JM, Reisine ST. The importance of physician encouragement in breast cancer screening of older women. Prev Med 1992; 21: 766–80.
- Fox SA, Stein JA. The effect of physician-patient communication on mammography utilization by different ethnic groups. Med Care 1991; 29: 1065–82.
- ↵Fox SA, Siu AL, Stein JA. The importance of physician communication on breast cancer screening of older women. Arch Intern Med 1994; 154: 2058–68.
- ↵Vernon SW, Laville EA, Jackson GL. Participation in breast screening programs: a review. Soc Sci Med 1990; 30: 1107–18.
- Bastani R, Marcus AC, Hollatz-Brown A. Screening mammography rates and barriers to use: a Los Angeles County survey. Prev Med 1991; 20: 350–63.
- ↵
- Lerman C, Caputo C, Brody D. Factors associated with inadequate cervical cancer screening among lower income primary care patients. J Am Board Fam Pract 1990; 3: 151–6.
- ↵Harlan LC, Bernstein AB, Kessler LG. Cervical cancer screening: who is not screened and why? Am J Public Health 1991; 81: 885–90.
- ↵Mandelblatt J, Traxler M, Lakin P, Kanetsky P, Kao R. Mammography and Papanicolaou smear use by elderly poor black women. The Harlem Study Team. J Am Geriatr Soc 1992; 40: 1001–7.
- ↵
- ↵
- ↵Perez-Stable EJ, Otero-Sabogal R, Sabogal F, McPhee SJ, Hiatt RA. Self-reported use of cancer screening tests among Latinos and Anglos in a prepaid health plan. Arch Intern Med 1994; 154: 1073–81.
- ↵Lantz PM, Weigers ME, House JS. Education and income differentials in breast and cervical cancer screening. Policy implications for rural women. Med Care 1997; 35: 219–36.
- ↵McPhee SJ, Richard RJ, Solkowitz SN. Performance of cancer screening in a university general internal medicine practice: comparison with the 1980 American Cancer Society Guidelines. J Gen Intern Med 1986; 1: 275–81.
- ↵
- ↵
- ↵Ives DG, Lave JR, Traven ND, Schulz R, Kuller LH. Mammography and Pap smear use by older rural women. Public Health Rep 1996; 111: 244–50.
- Weinrich S, Coker AL, Weinrich M, Eleazer GP, Greene FL. Predictors of Pap smear screening in socioeconomically disadvantaged elderly women. J Am Geriatr Soc 1995; 43: 267–70.
- ↵Rimer BK, Conaway MR, Lyna PR, et al. Cancer screening practices among women in a community health center population. Am J Prev Med 1996; 12: 351–7.
- ↵Buller D, Modiano MR, Guernsey de Zapien J, Meister J, Saltzman S, Hunsaker F. Predictors of cervical cancer screening in Mexican American women of reproductive age. J Health Care Poor Underserved 1998; 9: 76–94.
- ↵Ornstein SM, Garr DR, Jenkins RG, Rust PF, Zemp L, Arnon A. Compliance with five health promotion recommendations in a university-based family practice. J Fam Pract 1989; 29: 163–8.
- ↵Kirkman-Liff B, Kronenfeld JJ. Access to cancer screening services for women. Am J Public Health 1992; 82: 733–5.
- Katz SJ, Hofer TP. Socioeconomic disparities in preventive care persists despite universal coverage. Breast and cervical cancer screening in Ontario and the United States. JAMA 1994; 272: 530–4.
- ↵O’Malley AS, Mandelblatt J, Gold K, Cagney KA, Kerner J. Continuity of care and the use of breast and cervical cancer screening services in a multiethnic community. Arch Intern Med 1997; 157: 1462–70.
- ↵
- ↵Skaer TL, Robison LM, Sclar DA, Harding GH. Cancer-screening determinants among Hispanic women using migrant health clinics. J Health Care Poor Underserved 1996; 7: 338–54.
- ↵
- Rutledge DN, Hartmann WH, Kinman PO, Winfield AC. Exploration of factors affecting mammography behaviors. Prev Med 1988; 17: 412–22.
- Vincent AL, Greene JN, Hoercherl S, McTague D. Women at risk: Papanicolaou smear screening in Florida. J Fla Med Assoc 1997; 84: 302–7.
- Stearns SC, Slifkin RT, Edin HM. Access to care for rural Medicare beneficiaries. J Rural Health 2000; 16: 31–42.
- ↵Suarez L. Pap smear and mammogram screening in Mexican-American women: the effects of acculturation. Am J Public Health 1994; 84: 742–6.
- ↵Suarez L, Roche RA, Nichols D, Simpson DM. Knowledge, behavior, and fears concerning breast and cervical cancer among older low-income Mexican-American women. Am J Prev Med 1997; 13: 137–42.
- ↵Goldsmith DF, Sisneros GC. Cancer prevention strategies among California farm workers: preliminary findings. J Rural Health 1996; 12(4 Suppl): 343–8.
- Strickland J, Strickland DL. Barriers to preventive health services for minority households in the rural south. J Rural Health 1996; 12: 206–17.
- ↵
- ↵Vellozzi CJ, Romans M, Rothenberg RB. Delivering breast and cervical cancer screening services to underserved women: Part I. Literature review and telephone survey. Womens Health Issues 1996; 6: 65–73.
- Perez-Stable EJ, Sabogal F, Otero-Sabogal R, Hiatt RA, McPhee SJ. Misconceptions about cancer among Latinos and Anglos. JAMA 1992; 268: 3219–23.
- ↵Kraut AM. Healers and strangers. Immigrant attitudes toward the physician in America—a relationship in historical perspective. JAMA 1990; 263: 1807–11.
- Tosomeen AH, Marquez MA, Panser LA, Kottke TE. Developing preventive health programs for recent immigrants. A case study of cancer screening for Vietnamese women in Olmsted County, Minnesota. Minn Med 1996; 79: 46–8.
- ↵Penn NE, Kar S, Kramer J, Skinner J, Zambrana RE. Ethnic minorities, health care systems, and behavior. Health Psychol 1995; 14: 641–6.
- ↵
- ↵Marcus AC, Crane LA. A review of cervical cancer screening intervention research: implications for public health programs and future research. Prev Med 1998; 27: 13–31.
- ↵Cervical cancer screening. The Pap smear. Summary of an NIH consensus statement. Br Med J 1980; 281: 1264–6.
- ↵Allen JD, Stoddard AM, Mays J, Sorensen G. Promoting breast and cervical cancer screening at the workplace: results from the Woman to Woman Study. Am J Public Health 2001; 91: 584–90.
- ↵Paskett ED, Tatum CM, D’Agostino R, et al. Community-based interventions to improve breast and cervical cancer screening: results of the Forsyth County Cancer Screening (FoCaS) Project. Cancer Epidemiol Biomarkers Prev 1999; 8: 453–9.
- ↵Suarez L, Roche RA, Pulley L, Weiss NS, Goldman D, Simpson DM. Why a peer intervention program for Mexican-American women failed to modify the secular trend in cancer screening. Am J Prev Med 1997; 13: 411–7.
- ↵Jenkins CN, McPhee SJ, Bird JA, et al. Effect of a media-led education campaign on breast and cervical cancer screening among Vietnamese-American women. Prev Med 1999; 28: 395–406.
- ↵Bird JA, McPhee SJ, Ha NT, Le B, Davis T, Jenkins CN. Opening pathways to cancer screening for Vietnamese-American women: lay health workers hold a key. Prev Med 1998; 27: 821–9.
- Margolis KL, Lurie N, McGovern PG, Tyrrell M, Slater JS. Increasing breast and cervical cancer screening in low-income women. J Gen Intern Med 1998; 13: 515–21.
- ↵Navarro AM, Senn KL, McNicholas LJ, Kaplan RM, Roppe B, Campo MC. Por La Vida model intervention enhances use of cancer screening tests among Latinas. Am J Prev Med 1998; 15: 32–41.
- ↵Burack RC, Gimotty PA, George J, et al. How reminders given to patients and physicians affected Pap smear use in a health maintenance organization: results of a randomized controlled trial. Cancer 1998; 82: 2391–400.
- ↵Binstock MA, Geiger AM, Hackett JR, Yao JF. Pap smear outreach: a randomized controlled trial in an HMO. Am J Prev Med 1997; 13: 425–6.
- ↵Sung JF, Blumenthal DS, Coates RJ, Williams JE, Alema-Mensah E, Liff JM. Effect of a cancer screening intervention conducted by lay health workers among inner-city women. Am J Prev Med 1997; 13: 51–7.
- ↵Dignan M, Michielutte R, Blinson K, et al. Effectiveness of health education to increase screening for cervical cancer among eastern-band Cherokee Indian women in North Carolina. J Natl Cancer Inst 1996; 88: 1670–6.
- ↵Yancey AK, Tanjasiri SP, Klein M, Tunder J. Increased cancer screening behavior in women of color by culturally sensitive video exposure. Prev Med 1995; 24: 142–8.
- ↵
- ↵Dickersin K, Scherer R, Lefebvre C. Identifying relevant studies for systematic reviews. BMJ 1994; 309: 1286–91.
- ↵
- ↵Cheney C, Ramsdell JW. Effect of medical records’ checklists on implementation of periodic health measures. Am J Med 1987; 83: 129–36.
- ↵Clementz GL, Aldag JC, Gladfelter TT, Barclay AM, Brooks HF. A randomized study of cancer screening in a family practice setting using a recall model. J Fam Pract 1990; 30: 537–41.
- ↵Cowan JA, Heckerling PS, Parker JB. Effect of a fact sheet reminder on performance of the periodic health examination: a randomized controlled trial. Am J Prev Med 1992; 8: 104–9.
- ↵Dickey LL, Petitti D. A patient-held mini record to promote adult preventive care. J Fam Pract 1992; 34: 457–63.
- ↵Dietrich AJ, O’Connor GT, Keller A, Carney PA, Levy D, Whaley FS. Cancer: improving early detection and prevention. A community practice randomised trial. BMJ 1992; 304: 687–91.
- ↵Dietrich AJ, Tobin JN, Sox CH, et al. Cancer early-detection services in community health centers for the underserved. A randomized controlled trial. Arch Fam Med 1998; 7: 320–7.
- ↵Gemson DH, Ashford AR, Dickey LL, et al. Putting prevention into practice. Impact of a multifaceted physician education program on preventive services in the inner city. Arch Intern Med 1995; 155: 2210–6.
- ↵Gotay CC, Banner RO, Matsunaga DS, et al. Impact of a culturally appropriate intervention on breast and cervical screening among native Hawaiian women. Prev Med 2000; 31: 529–37.
- ↵Hillman AL, Ripley K, Goldfarb N, Nuamah I, Weiner J, Lusk E. Physician financial incentives and feedback: failure to increase cancer screening in Medicaid managed care. Am J Prev Med 1998; 88: 1699–701.
- ↵Kreuter MW, Strecher VJ. Do tailored behavior change messages enhance the effectiveness of health risk appraisal? Results from a randomized trial. Health Educ Res 1996; 11: 97–105.
- ↵Lantz PM, Stencil D, Lippert MT, Beversdorf S, Jaros L, Remington PL. Breast and cervical cancer screening in a low-income managed care sample: the efficacy of physician letters and phone calls. Am J Public Health 1995; 85: 834–6.
- ↵Litzelman DK, Dittus RS, Miller ME, Tierney WM. Requiring physicians to respond to computerized reminders improves their compliance with preventive care protocols. J Gen Intern Med 1993; 8: 311–7.
- ↵Mandelblatt J, Traxler M, Lakin P, et al. A nurse practitioner intervention to increase breast and cervical cancer screening for poor, elderly black women. The Harlem Study Team. J Gen Intern Med 1993; 8: 173–8.
- ↵Manfredi C, Czaja R, Freels S, Trubitt M, Warnecke R, Lacey L. Prescribe for health. Improving cancer screening in physician practices serving low-income and minority populations. Arch Fam Med 1998; 7: 329–37.
- ↵McDonald CJ, Hui SL, Smith DM, et al. Reminders to physicians from an introspective computer medical record. A two-year randomized trial. Ann Intern Med 1984; 100: 130–8.
- ↵McPhee SJ, Bird JA, Jenkins CN, Fordham D. Promoting cancer screening. A randomized, controlled trial of three interventions. Arch Intern Med 1989; 149: 1866–72.
- ↵McPhee SJ, Bird JA, Fordham D, Rodnick JE, Osborn EH. Promoting cancer prevention activities by primary care physicians. Results of a randomized, controlled trial. JAMA 1991; 266: 538–44.
- Melnikow J, Kohatsu ND, Chan BK. Put prevention into practice: a controlled evaluation. Am J Public Health 2000; 90: 1622–5.
- ↵Ornstein SM, Garr DR, Jenkins RG, Rust PF, Arnon A. Computer-generated physician and patient reminders. Tools to improve population adherence to selected preventive services. J Fam Pract 1991; 32: 82–90.
- Reding DJ, Lappe KA, Krueger M, Kolehouse BL, Steneil D, Leer RA. Cancer screening and prevention in rural Wisconsin: the Greater Marshfield experience. Wis Med J 1997; 96: 32–7.
- ↵Rimer BK, Conaway M, Lyna P, et al. The impact of tailored interventions on a community health center population. Patient Educ Couns 1999; 37: 125–40.
- ↵Robie PW. Improving and sustaining outpatient cancer screening by medicine residents. South Med J 1988; 81: 902–5.
- ↵Schreiner DT, Petrusa ER, Rettie CS, Kluge RM. Improving compliance with preventive medicine procedures in a house staff training program. South Med J 1988; 81: 1553–7.
- ↵Somkin CP, Hiatt RA, Hurley LB, Gruskin E, Ackerson L, Larson P. The effect of patient and provider reminders on mammography and Papanicolaou smear screening in large health maintenance organization. Arch Intern Med 1997; 157: 1658–64.
- ↵
- ↵Tape TG, Campbell JR. Computerized medical records and preventive health care: success depends on many factors. Am J Med 1993; 94: 619–25.
- ↵Tierney WM, Hui SL, McDonald CJ. Delayed feedback of physician performance versus immediate reminders to perform preventive care. Effects on physician compliance. Med Care 1986; 24: 659–66.
- ↵Turner RC, Waivers LE, O’Brien K. The effect of patient-carried reminder cards on the performance of health maintenance measures. Arch Intern Med 1990; 150: 645–7.
- ↵Turner BJ, Day SC, Borenstein B. A controlled trial to improve delivery of preventive care: physician or patient reminders? J Gen Intern Med 1989; 4: 403–9.
- ↵Whitman S, Lacey L, Ansell D, Dell J, Chen E, Phillips CW. An intervention to increase breast and cervical cancer screening in low-income African-American women. Fam Community Health 1994; 17: 56–63.
- ↵Williams RB, Boles M, Johnson RE. A patient-initiated system for preventive health care: a randomized trial in community-based primary care practices. Arch Fam Med 1998; 7: 338–45.
- ↵Becker DM, Gomez EB, Kaiser DL, Yoshihasi A, Hodge RH Jr. Improving preventive care at a medical clinic: how can the patient help? Am J Prev Med 1989; 5: 353–9.
- ↵Fineberg MV, Funkhouser AR, Marks M. Variation in medical practice: A review of the literature. In: Eisenberg JM, editor. Doctors’ decisions and the cost of medical care. The reasons for doctors’ practice patterns and ways to change. Ann Arbor: Health Administration Press, 1986: 137–38.
- ↵
- ↵
- ↵Mandelblatt J, Freeman H, Winczewski D, et al. Implementation of a breast and cervical cancer screening program in a public hospital emergency department. Cancer Control Center of Harlem. Ann Emerg Med 1996; 28: 493–8.
- ↵Doyle JP, Parker RM, Jacobson TA, McNagny SE. Breast and cervical cancer screening in an inner-city medical walk-in clinic: taking advantage of an often missed opportunity. Am J Prev Med 1996; 12: 345–50.
- ↵Holschneider CH, Felix JC, Satmary W, Johnson MT, Sandweiss LM, Montz FJ. A single-visit cervical carcinoma prevention program offered at an inner city church. A pilot project. Cancer 1999; 86: 2659–67.
- ↵Mandelblatt J, Freeman H, Winczewski D, et al. The costs and effects of cervical cancer screening in a public hospital emergency room. The Cancer Control Center of Harlem. Am J Public Health 1997; 87: 1182–9.
- ↵Yabroff KR, Mandelblatt JS. Interventions targeted toward patients to increase mammography use. Cancer Epidemiol Biomarkers Prev 1999; 8: 749–57.
- ↵Mandelblatt JS, Yabroff KR. Effectiveness of interventions designed to increase mammography use: a meta-analysis of provider-targeted strategies. Cancer Epidemiol Biomarkers Prev 1999; 8: 759–67.
- ↵Paskett ED, Tatum CM, Mack DW, Hoen H, Case LD, Velez R. Validation of self-reported breast and cervical cancer screening tests among low-income minority women. Cancer Epidemiol Biomarkers Prev 1996; 5: 721–6.
- Sawyer JA, Earp JA, Fletcher RH, Daye FF, Wynn TM. Accuracy of women’s self-report of their last Pap smear. Am J Public Health 1989; 79: 1036–7.
- Etzi S, Lane DS, Grimson R. The use of mammography vans by low-income women: the accuracy of self-reports. Am J Public Health 1994; 84: 107–9.
- Suarez L, Goldman DA, Weiss NS. Validity of Pap smear and mammogram self-reports in a low-income Hispanic population. Am J Prev Med 1995; 11: 94–8.
- Gordon NP, Hiatt RA, Lampert DI. Concordance of self-reported data and medical record audit for six cancer screening procedures. J Natl Cancer Inst 1993; 85: 566–70.
- ↵Divine GW, Brown JT, Frazier LM. The unit of analysis error in studies about physicians’ patient care behavior. J Gen Intern Med 1992; 7: 623–9.
In this issue
Effectiveness of Interventions to Increase Papanicolaou Smear Use
K. Robin Yabroff, Patricia Mangan, Jeanne Mandelblatt
The Journal of the American Board of Family
Practice May 2003, 16 (3) 188-203; DOI: 10.3122/jabfm.16.3.188
Jump to section
Related Articles
- No related articles found.
Cited By...
- No citing articles found.