Recruiting older adults for clinical trials

doi:10.1016/S0197-2456(96)00132-8

Controlled Clinical Trials

Volume 18, Issue 1, February 1997, Pages 14-26

https://doi.org/10.1016/S0197-2456(96)00132-8 Get rights and content

Abstract

More than 400 community-dwelling older adults were recruited into a clinical trial which compared the effectiveness of diagnosis and treatment through geriatric assessment with that provided through usual community physician care. Six recruitment methods were utilized: referrals, solicitations, presentations, media, mailings, and fliers. Each method is described and its results reported in terms of numbers recruited, yield, and cost per participant. The most efficient method was referrals; the method producing the largest number was presentations; the least effective method was fliers. Problems and solutions are discussed, and guidelines for recruiting older adults are suggested. These guidelines include: monitoring with accompanying adaptation, targeting the groups most likely to benefit, providing incentives, and reducing uncertainty among potential participants.

References (39)

CA Silagy et al.
Comparison of recruitment strategies for a large-scale clinical trial in the elderly
J Clin Epdemiol
(1991)
JW Kusek et al.
Recruitment experience in the full-scale phase of the modification of diet in renal disease study
Control Clin Trials
(1993)
DB Hunninghake et al.
Recruitment experience in clinical studies: literature summary and annotated bibliography
Control Clin Trials
(1987)
HA Lando
Inexpensive methods for recruiting subjects to smoking cessation programs
Addict Behav
(1982)
NO Borhani et al.
Recruitment in the Hypertension Prevention trial. Hypertension Prevention Trial Research Group
Control Clin Trials
(1989)
DG Ives et al.
Comparison of recruitment strategies and associated disease prevalence for health promotion in rural elderly
Prev Med
(1992)
WM Vollmer et al.
Recruiting children and their families for clinical trials: a case study
Control Clin Trials
(1992)
LA Panser et al.
Effect of several recruitment strategies on response rates at baseline in a prospective cohort investigation
Ann Epidemiol
(1994)
TM Vogt et al.
Recruitment of elderly volunteers for a multicenter clinical trial: the SHEP pilot study
Control Clin Trials
(1986)
WS Agras et al.
Recruitment for clinical trials: the lipid research clinic's coronary primary prevention trial experience. Its implications for future trials
Circulation
(1982)

RS Ashery et al.

Implementation issues and techniques in randomized trials of outpatient psychosocial treatments for drug abusers: recruitment of sujects

Am J Drug Alcohol Abuse

(1992)

LM Friedman et al.

WM Bjornson-Benson et al.

Monitoring recruitment effectiveness and cost in a clinical trial

Control Clin Trials

(1993)

WS Agras et al.

Recruitment for Coronary Primary Prevention Trial

Clin Pharmacol Ther

(1979)

S Cobb et al.

Differences between respondents and non-respondents in a morbidity survey involving clinical examination

J Chron Dis

(1957)

T Eaton et al.

A clinic's perspective on screening, recruitment and data collection

Stat Med

(1990)

MA Leader et al.

Clinical research and the noninstitutional elderly: a model for subject recruitment

J Am Geriatr Soc

(1978)

DE Williams et al.

Successful recruitment of elderly community-dwelling subjects for Alzheimer's disease research

J Gerontol

(1988)

RW Chang et al.

Prerandomization: an alternative to classic randomization. The effects on recruitment in a controlled trial of arthroscopy for osteoarthrosis of the knee

J Bone Joint Surg

(1990)

Cited by (69)

Text Parsing-Based Identification of Patients with Poor Glaucoma Medication Adherence in the Electronic Health Record
2021, American Journal of Ophthalmology
To assess the feasibility of automated text parsing screening of physician notes in the electronic health record (EHR) to identify glaucoma patients with poor medication compliance.
Cross-sectional study.
An automated EHR extraction identified a cohort of patients at the University of Michigan with a diagnosis of glaucoma, ≥40 years old, taking ≥1 glaucoma medication, and having no cognitive impairment. Self-reported medication adherence was assessed with 2 validated instruments: the Chang scale and the Morisky medication adherence scale. In tandem, a text parsing tool that abstracted data from the EHR was used to search for combinations of the following words in patient visit notes: “not,” “non,” “n't,” “no,” or “poor” accompanied by “adherence,” “adherent, “adhering,” “compliance,” “compliant,” or “complying.” The proportion of patients with self-reported poor adherence was compared between the EHR extraction and text parsing identification using a Fisher exact test.
Among 736 participants, 20.0% (n = 147) self-reported poor adherence and 6.1% (n = 45) had EHR documentation of poor adherence (P < .0001). Using text parsing as a pre-screening tool, 22 of the 45 patients (48.9%) with non-adherence identified by text parsing also self-reported poor medication adherence compared to the 20.0% by self-report overall (P < .0001).
Text parsing physician notes to identify patients' noncompliance to their medications identified a larger proportion of patients who then self-reported poor medication adherence than an automated EHR pull alone but was limited by the small number of patients identified. Optimizing the documentation of medication adherence would maximize the utility of this automated approach to identify medication noncompliance.
Magnetic Resonance Imaging and Spectroscopy to Assess Leg Muscle Macrostructure and Microstructure in Healthy Older Women: A Feasibility Assessment
2017, Journal of Medical Imaging and Radiation Sciences
Advanced magnetic resonance (MR) scanning techniques, such as diffusion tensor imaging (DTI) and proton MR spectroscopy (¹H-MRS) permit microstructural evaluation of water diffusivity and intramyocellular lipid content, respectively. We aimed to determine the feasibility of performing advanced MR scanning (proton density [PD] weighted imaging, DTI, and ¹H-MRS) to evaluate properties of leg muscles in older women with respect to: (1) participant recruitment using three community-based strategies; (2) participant tolerance to the MRI scan acquisition protocol; and (3) scan acquisition and analyses protocols.
Recruitment feasibility was evaluated based on the number of participants enrolled using various strategies. Participant tolerance was feasible if the scanning session was uninterrupted and image artifacts were absent. Optimal PD imaging, DTI, and ¹H-MRS acquisition and analyses protocols were established.
Nine women (mean age = 71 years) were recruited over four months. The acquisition protocol was well tolerated by all participants. Adaptations were required for women with short stature and vertebral fracture risk. PD-weighted image analyses were improved by using the phased array uniformity enhancement filter to increase tissue contrast.
It is feasible to use a combination of MR scanning methods to evaluate muscle macrostructure and microstructure in the leg of older women. Our findings suggest that advanced MR scanning methods can be used for future studies interested in quantifying components of muscle structure in older women, but prospective studies are needed to confirm whether change in microstructure can be detected in response to an intervention.
Les techniques avancées de résonance magnétique, comme l'imagerie du tenseur de diffusion (ITD) et la spectroscopie par résonance magnétique protonique (SRM-1H) permettent respectivement l’évaluation microstructurale de la diffusivité de la vapeur d'eau et du contenu lipidique intracellulaire. Les auteurs visent à déterminer la faisabilité de l'utilisation des techniques RM avancées (imagerie pondérée en densité de protons, ITD et SRM-1H) afin d’évaluer les propriétés des muscles de la jambe chez les femmes âgées en fonction des éléments suivants: 1) recrutement des participantes en utilisant trois stratégies basées sur la communauté; 2) la tolérance des participantes au protocole d'acquisition d'images et 3) les protocoles d'acquisition et d'analyse des images.
La faisabilité du recrutement a été évaluée à partir du nombre de participantes inscrites en utilisant différentes stratégies. La tolérance des participantes était acceptable si la séance de balayage se déroulait sans interruption et que les images ne présentaient par d'artefacts. Des protocoles optimaux ont été établis pour l'imagerie pondérée en densité de protons, l’ITD et la SRM-1H.
Neuf femmes (âge moyen = 71 ans) ont été recrutées sur une période de quatre mois. Le protocole d'acquisition a été bien toléré par toutes les participantes. Des adaptations ont été nécessaires pour des femmes de petite taille et présentant un risque de fracture vertébrale. Les analyses d'imagerie pondérée en densité de protons ont été améliorées par l'utilisation du filtre d'amélioration de l'uniformité du faisceau de radiation pour augmenter le contraste des tissus.
Il est possible d'utiliser une combinaison de méthodes de balayage RM pour évaluer la macrostructure et la microstructure musculaires de la jambe chez les femmes plus âgées. Nos conclusions indiquent que les méthodes d’IRM avancées peuvent être utilisées pour d'autres études visant à quantifier les composantes de la structure musculaire des femmes plus âgées, mais des études prospectives seront nécessaires pour confirmer si des changements de microstructure peuvent être détectés en réponse à une intervention.
Concept and implementation of a study dashboard module for a continuous monitoring of trial recruitment and documentation
2016, Journal of Biomedical Informatics
Citation Excerpt :
A ‘comprehensive data-monitoring process with the capability of rapid feedback’ has been advised that should allow for ‘considering alternative strategies if recruitment is lagging’ [6]. We would therefore expect the utility of monitoring accrual to be pronounced if diverse recruitment methods are available, in particular if their efficiency is disparate or unclear [4,8,9,59,60]. The insight that ‘unanticipated difficulties are highly likely at some time’ generally calls for a ‘proactive approach to monitoring ongoing trials’ [3].
The difficulty of managing patient recruitment and documentation for clinical trials prompts a demand for instruments for closely monitoring these critical but unpredictable processes. Increasingly adopted Electronic Data Capture (EDC) applications provide novel opportunities to reutilize stored information for an efficient management of traceable trial workflows. In related clinical and administrative settings, so-called digital dashboards that continuously visualize time-dependent parameters have recently met a growing acceptance. To investigate the technical feasibility of a study dashboard for monitoring the progress of patient recruitment and trial documentation, we set out to develop a propositional prototype in the form of a separate software module.
After narrowing down functional requirements in semi-structured interviews with study coordinators, we analyzed available interfaces of a locally deployed EDC application, and designed the prototypical study dashboard based on previous findings. The module thereby leveraged a standardized export format in order to extract and import relevant trial data into a clinical data warehouse. Web-based reporting tools then facilitated the definition of diverse views, including diagrams of the progress of patient accrual and form completion at different granularity levels. To estimate the utility of the dashboard and its compatibility with current workflows, we interviewed study coordinators after a demonstration of sample outputs from ongoing trials.
The employed tools promoted a rapid development. Displays of the implemented dashboard are organized around an entry page that integrates key metrics for available studies, and which links to more detailed information such as study-specific enrollment per center. The interviewed experts commented that the included graphical summaries appeared suitable for detecting that something was generally amiss, although practical remedies would mostly depend on additional information such as access to the original patient-specific data. The dependency on a separate application was seen as a downside. Interestingly, the prospective users warned that in some situations knowledge of specific accrual statistics might undermine blinding in a subtle yet intricate fashion, so ignorance of certain patient features was seen as sometimes preferable for reproducibility.
Our proposed study dashboard graphically recaps key progress indicators of patient accrual and trial documentation. The modular implementation illustrates the technical feasibility of the approach. The use of a study dashboard might introduce certain technical requirements as well as subtle interpretative complexities, which may have to be weighed against potential efficiency gains.
Assessing physical and cognitive function of older adults in continuing care retirement communities: Who are we recruiting?
2015, Contemporary Clinical Trials
In partnership with six Continuing Care Retirement Communities (CCRCs), the current study focused on the feasibility of recruiting a representative sample of residents and then assessing their functional health.
With our guidance, each of the six CCRCs recruited a volunteer (V-Group) and random (R-Group) sample of independent living residents. We provided face-to-face training and ongoing remote electronic support to the CCRC staff on the testing battery and the Web-based data entry system. The testing battery was consisted of demographic, physical function, and psychosocial assessments.
After training, CCRC staff were receptive to the study goals and successfully used the data entry Website. In the V-Group (N = 189), 76% were already participating in CCRC wellness programs. We attempted to recruit a random, unbiased (R-Group) sample of 20% (n = 105) of eligible residents; however, only 30 consented to be tested and 70% of this group (21/30) were also already participating in a wellness program. Mean age of all participants was 82.9 years. The V-Group had a higher Short Physical Performance Battery (SPPB) total score (least squares mean [SE], 9.4 [0.2] vs 8.2 [0.4], p = 0.014) and SPPB gait speed component score (3.5 [0.1] vs 3.0 [0.2], p = 0.007) and spent more time doing moderate-to-vigorous physical activity (300 [21] vs 163 [49] min/week, p = 0.013) compared to the R-Group.
While it is feasible to recruit, assess and transmit data on residents' functional health in partnership with CCRCs, population validity was severely compromised. Attention needs to be given to the development of more effective methods to recruit less interested residents.
Challenges and strategies pertaining to recruitment and retention of frail elderly in research studies: A systematic review
2014, Archives of Gerontology and Geriatrics
Recruitment and retention of frail elderly in research studies can be difficult.
To identify challenges and strategies pertaining to recruitment and retention of frail elderly in research studies.
A systematic review was conducted. Four databases (MEDLINE, CINAHL, AgeLine, Embase) were searched from January 1992 to December 2012. Empirical studies were included if they explored barriers to or strategies for recruitment or retention of adults aged 60-plus who were identified as frail, vulnerable or housebound. Two researchers independently determined the eligibility of each abstract reviewed and assessed the level of evidence presented. Data concerning challenges encountered (type and impact) and strategies used (type and impact) were abstracted.
Of 916 articles identified in the searches, 15 met the inclusion criteria. The level of evidence of the studies retained varied from poor to good. Lack of perceived benefit, distrust of research staff, poor health and mobility problems were identified as common challenges. The most frequently reported strategies used were to establish a partnership with staff that participants knew and trusted, and be flexible about the time and place of the study. However, few studies performed analyses to compare the impact of specific challenges and strategies on refusal or drop-out rates.
This review highlights the need to improve knowledge about the impact of barriers and strategies on recruitment and retention of frail older adults. This knowledge will help to develop innovative and cost-effective ways to increase and maintain participation, which may improve the generalizability of research findings to this population.
Designing clinical trials in older people
2011, Maturitas
Adequate medical care of the increasingly ageing population requires robust clinical trial data both to inform treatment decisions, and to understand the natural history of diseases which primarily affect the elderly. However, this information is widely lacking, which is likely to have significant clinical consequences. Under-representation of older people in clinical trials is well documented, the reasons including physicians’ perception, protocol eligibility criteria, and functional status requirements. Many clinical trial designs remain conservative and there is no established standardised methodology for recruiting more elderly patients with co-morbidities and disability into clinical trials. Designing clinical trials in older people poses a unique set of challenges, particularly regarding recruitment, retention and data analysis. In this review we outline the difficulties encountered in conducting clinical trials in older patients and describe some of the initiatives that can be put in place to counteract them. It is only by addressing these challenges with careful and adequately resourced protocol design that clinical trials may successfully address the therapeutic questions raised by our ageing population.

View all citing articles on Scopus

^☆: Support for this work provided by the National Institute on Aging grant HCT 5 R01 AG08276, and the Howard Heinz Endowment.

^∗: J. Adams' former address was Graduate School of Public Health, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, PA.

View full text

Recruiting older adults for clinical trials☆

Abstract

J Clin Epdemiol

Control Clin Trials

Control Clin Trials

Addict Behav

Control Clin Trials

Prev Med

Control Clin Trials

Ann Epidemiol

Control Clin Trials

Recruitment for clinical trials: the lipid research clinic's coronary primary prevention trial experience. Its implications for future trials

Circulation

Implementation issues and techniques in randomized trials of outpatient psychosocial treatments for drug abusers: recruitment of sujects

Am J Drug Alcohol Abuse

Monitoring recruitment effectiveness and cost in a clinical trial

Control Clin Trials

Recruitment for Coronary Primary Prevention Trial

Clin Pharmacol Ther

Differences between respondents and non-respondents in a morbidity survey involving clinical examination

J Chron Dis

A clinic's perspective on screening, recruitment and data collection

Stat Med

Clinical research and the noninstitutional elderly: a model for subject recruitment

J Am Geriatr Soc

Successful recruitment of elderly community-dwelling subjects for Alzheimer's disease research

J Gerontol

Prerandomization: an alternative to classic randomization. The effects on recruitment in a controlled trial of arthroscopy for osteoarthrosis of the knee

J Bone Joint Surg