Table 1.

Step 1 Nonopioid Analgesics

Drug (Brand name) Rx or OTCUsual Starting DoseMaximum Daily DoseCommentsCost/day*
    Acetaminophen (Tylenol, others) OTC650 mg q4–6 hours4000 mg1000 mg is more effective than 650 mg in some patients<$1.00
    Aspirin (various) OTC650 mg q4–6 hours4000 mgMay not be tolerated as well as some newer NSAIDs.<$1.00
    Diflunisal (Dolobid) Rx1000 mg ×1 then 500 mg q12 hours1500 mgDerived from salicylic acid. Little antipyretic activity$2.80
Nonacetylated Salicylates
    Choline magnesium trisalicylate (Trilisate, others) Rx1500 mg ×1 then 1000 mg q12 hours3000 mgEffective anti-inflammatory drugs, but less effective analgesics than aspirin. Have minimal antiplatelet effect and do not alter bleeding time. Aspirin cross-sensitivity less likely to occur.$3.00
    Salsalate (Disalcid, others) Rx1500 mg ×1 then 1000 mg q12 hours3000 mg$2.50
Other NSAIDs: Propionic Acid
    Fenoprofen (Nalfon, others) Rx200 mg q4–6 hours1200 mg90% eliminated by the kidney.$3.40
    Flurbiprofen (Ansaid, others) Rx50 mg q8–12 hours300 mgAt high doses, monitor closely for side effects.$1.00
    Ibuprofen (Rx: Motrin, others; OTC: Advil, Nuprin, others)400 mg q4–6 hours; OTC use: 200–400 mg q4–6 hours2400 mg; OTC 1200 mg200 mg ≈ 650 mg aspirin or APAP. 400 mg ≈ codeine/APAP$1.60
    Ketoprofen (Rx: Orudis, others; OTC: Actron, Orudis-KT)25–50 mg q6–8 hours; OTC use: 12.5–25 mg q4–6 hours300 mg; OTC 75 mg12.5 mg ≈ 200 mg ibuprofen; 50 mg superior to codeine/APAP$3.60
    Naproxen (Naprosyn, others) Rx500 mg ×1 then 500 mg q12 hours or 250 mg q6–8 hours1250 mg first day then 1000 mg250 mg ≈ 650 mg aspirin with longer duration. 95% eliminated by the kidney.<$1.00
    Naproxen sodium (Rx: Anaprox, others; OTC: Aleve, others)550 mg ×1 then 550 mg q12 hours or 275 mg q6–8 hours; OTC use: 220–440 mg ×1 then 220 mg q8–12 hours1375 mg first day then 1100 mg; OTC 660 mg275 mg ≈ 650 mg aspirin with longer duration; OTC 440 mg ≈ 400 mg ibuprofen. 95% eliminated by the kidney. Naproxen sodium may have less dyspepsia than naproxen<$1.00
    Oxaprozin (Daypro) Rx600–1200 mg qd1800 mgLong serum half-life (42–50 hours)$1.66
Other NSAIDs: Acetic Acid
    Diclofenac potassium (Cataflam, others) Rx50 mg q8 hours or 75 mg bid150 mgMay have less dyspepsia than the sodium salt.$1.10
    Diclofenac sodium (Voltaren, others; extended-release: Voltaren XR, others) Rx50 mg q8 hours or 75 mg bid; extended-release 100 mg qd150 mg; for Voltaren XR 100 mgAlso available with misoprostol 200 μg (Arthrotec 50 mg, 75 mg) to decrease GI toxicity.$1.00
    Etodolac (Lodine, others; extended-release: Lodine XL) Rx200–400 mg q6–8 hours; Lodine XL 400 mg qd1200 mg; for Lodine XL 1000 mg200 mg ≈ 650 mg aspirin or APAP$2.70
    Indomethacin (Indocin, other; sustained release: Indocin SR, others) Rx25 mg q8–12 hours; sustained release 75 mg qd200 mg; for Indocin SR 75 mg bidHigher incidence of side effects. Also available in oral suspension.<$1.00
    Ketorolac (Toradol)10 mg q4–6 hours40 mg91% eliminated by the kidney. Use lower dose if >65 years or <50kg. Do not use >5 days$3.70
    Sulindac (Clinoril, others) Rx150–200 mg bid400 mgHave few cases reporting less drug interaction with lithium<$1.00
    Tolmetin (Tolectin, others;) Rx200–600 tid1800 mg100% eliminated by the kidney.$1.65
Other NSAIDs: Fenamates
    Meclofenamate (various) Rx50–100 mg q4–6 hours400 mgComparable with aspirin. Commonly used for dysmenorrhea. Diarrhea is common$1.10
    Mefenamic acid (Ponstel) Rx500 mg ×1 then 250 mg q6 hours1250 mgEffective in dysmenorrhea. Do not use >1 week$5.20
Other NSAIDs: Naphthylalkanone
    Nabumetone (Relafen) Rx1000 mg qd2000 mgCan be given either qd or bid$2.40
Other NSAIDs: Oxicam
    Meloxicam (Mobic) Rx7.5 mg qd15 mgDose-dependent COX-2/COX-1 inhibition$2.00
    Piroxicam (Feldene, others) Rx20 mg qd20 mgLong serum half-life (50 hours). High incidence of side effects, especially in the elderly.<$1.00
COX-2 Inhibitors
    Celecoxib (Celebrex) RxAcute pain: 400–600 mg first day, then 200 mg bid400 mgContraindicated in sulfa allergy$4.70
    Valdecoxib (Bextra) RxDysmenorrhea: 20 mg bid40 mgApproved for osteoarthritis/rheumatoid arthritis and dysmenorrhea only$5.40
Injectable NSAIDs
    Ketorolac IV/IM (Toradol) Rx<65 years: 60 mg ×1 then 30 mg q6 hours; ≥65 years: 30 mg ×1 then 15 mg q6 hours120 mg91% eliminated by the kidney. Use lower dose if >65 or <50kg. Do not use >5 days$7.99 ea dose
  • * Cost/day = cost of usual daily dosage based on price listing at www.drugstore.com on 2003 Oct 21. Generic drugs were used whenever available.

  • qid, 4 times per day; tid, 3 times per day; bid, twice per day; qd, once per day; q, every.