Table 1.

Quality of Medical Care Experiences among Patients Seen by Primary Care Physicians Versus Specialists (Total Sample = 646)

Primary CareSpecialty CareSignificance*
PC (Sample Range: 261–281)Internal Medicine (Sample Range: 82–90)Family Medicine (Sample Range: 93–95)Pediatrics (Sample Range: 86–96)SC (Sample Range: 261–281)OBGyn (Sample Range: 79–88)Gastroenterology (Sample Range: 91–94)General Surgery (Sample Range: 85–91)Dermatology (Sample Range: 86–92)t TestANOVA
First contact (utilization)2.94 (0.73)2.91 (0.69)2.85 (0.74)3.05 (0.76)2.69 (1.00)2.43 (0.92)2.95 (1.38)2.67 (0.71)2.69 (0.78)3.53§5.18§
First contact (access)2.55 (0.72)2.61 (0.72)2.61 (0.68)2.44 (0.75)2.16 (0.74)2.11 (0.87)2.17 (0.69)2.19 (0.66)2.18 (0.76)6.73§8.20§
Ongoing care2.66 (0.75)2.66 (0.77)2.62 (0.65)2.70 (0.84)2.48 (0.73)2.30 (0.87)2.55 (0.67)2.54 (0.68)2.54 (0.67)2.952.70
Coordination (referral)2.72 (0.65)2.67 (0.64)2.69 (0.63)2.80 (0.69)2.58 (0.69)2.35 (0.83)2.77 (0.66)2.49 (0.57)2.68 (0.60)2.625.17§
Coordination information system2.70 (1.16)2.55 (0.74)2.87 (1.68)2.66 (0.76)2.52 (0.76)2.39 (0.83)2.63 (0.72)2.43 (0.74)2.60 (0.74)2.432.62
Comprehensiveness (services available)2.62 (0.76)2.54 (0.71)2.58 (0.70)2.73 (0.85)2.40 (0.83)2.48 (0.91)2.46 (0.76)2.19 (0.75)2.46 (0.86)3.47§3.84§
Comprehensiveness (Services provided)2.78 (0.73)2.65 (0.71)2.81 (0.62)2.88 (0.84)2.57 (0.72)2.35 (0.89)2.55 (0.71)2.65 (0.63)2.72 (0.58)3.60§5.29§
Family centeredness2.77 (0.76)2.67 (0.77)2.68 (0.68)2.97 (0.79)2.56 (0.80)2.41 (0.89)2.59 (0.71)2.51 (0.80)2.73 (0.77)3.38§4.84§
Community orientation2.28 (0.64)2.26 (0.65)2.24 (0.66)2.33 (0.61)2.00 (0.73)2.00 (0.78)2.19 (0.73)1.89 (0.63)1.94 (0.74)5.06§6.08§
Cultural competence2.65 (0.66)2.75 (0.69)2.65 (0.64)2.55 (0.66)2.46 (0.73)2.21 (0.79)2.61 (0.63)2.29 (0.78)2.69 (0.61)3.39§7.99§
Overall PC experience26.60 (5.32)26.21 (5.66)26.57 (5.10)27.00 (5.25)24.41 (5.65)23.01 (7.38)25.49 (5.08)23.90 (4.90)25.07 (4.75)4.81§5.85§
  • For each area of PC and SC listed, both minimum and maximum sample sizes are provided. Statistics included in the table are mean scores (SD) for the domains of health care experiences.

  • * t test compares PC with SC. ANOVA compares differences across specialties.

  • P < .05.

  • P < .01.

  • § P < .001.

  • PC, primary care; SC, specialty care; OBGyn, obstetrics/gynecology; ANOVA, analysis of variance.