Case | Body Area | Clinician Reading | Radiologist Reading | Change in Care | Outcome |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Foot | Normal | 2nd metatarsal stress fracture | Follow-up visit scheduled* | Continued pain at follow-up visit with normal radiographs 17 months later |
2 | Hand | Normal | Nondisplaced intra-articular fracture at base of 2nd metacarpal | Cast applied* | Continued to have pain 9 months later despite appropriate care |
3 | Left ribs and PA chest | Normal | Nondisplaced 5th, 6th and 7th rib fractures | New prescription for pain medication* | Pain improved at 5-week follow-up visit |
4 | Foot | Normal | Nondisplaced 5th proximal phalangeal shaft fracture | Gym excuse for 3 weeks* | No further follow up documented |
5 | Ankle | Normal | Impacted calcaneus fracture | Repeat radiographs* | No calcaneal pain 9 weeks later |
6 | Hand | Normal | Possible fracture of DIP dorsal spur | Additional office visit repeat radiographs* | Although patient free of pain or swelling, repeat radiographs were obtained. |
7 | PA and lateral chest | Lung infiltrate | No acute pulmonary disease | Cancelled possible CT* | Cough resolved |
8 | Lumbar spine, AP and lateral | ′No acute disease′ | Possible spondylolysis recommended additional radiographs | Additional radiographs† | No change in care for back pain |
9 | Abdomen | Normal | 6-mm nodule, base of lung | Additional radiographs† | ′Nodule′ not seen on repeat radiographs |
10 | PA and lateral chest | Normal | Bilateral lung nodules | Additional radiographs† | One nodule was nipple, other was not identified |
11 | PA and lateral chest | Normal | 1-cm lung nodule | Additional radiographs† | No further evaluation |
12 | Shoulder | Normal | Possible mild acromioclavicular subluxation, recommended additional radiographs | Additional radiographs† | Complete resolution of muscular shoulder strain, no change in care of shoulder |
13 | PA and lateral chest | Normal | Possible parenchymal opacity | Administrative effort to obtain old radiographs for comparison‡ | Possible parenchymal opacity was second rib |
14 | PA and lateral chest | Normal | Possible lung nodule | Administrative effort to obtain old radiographs for comparison‡ | Nodule stable for more than 2 years |
15 | Hand§ | Normal | Fracture at base of 5th proximal phalanx | None documented | Unknown |
16 | Thumb§ | Normal | Possible nondisplaced Salter-Harris type II fracture of distal phalanx | None documented | Unknown |
17 | Ankle§ | Normal | Possible medial malleolar avulsion fracture | None documented | Unknown |
18 | Thumb§ | Normal | Possible nondisplaced Salter-Harris type II fracture of distal phalanx | None documented | Unknown |
PA, posteroanterior.
* Presumed or documented 1 telephone contact for each case.
† Presumed or documented 2 telephone contacts for each case.
‡ Presumed or documented 3 telephone contacts for each case.
§ No follow up documented.